Doctor Science Knows

Sunday, January 01, 2006

How to Write Sex Well

Echidne of the snakes, goddess, notes that writing about sex well is hard, pointing to sex scenes in politicians' books for horrible examples. (though frankly, I find the quoted bit from Barbara Boxer's book doesn't actually qualify as a sex scene, except in a biological sense. It's about sex, but the POV is that of a detacted, veterinary observer, as far as I can tell. I don't get the impression that this is directly intended to arouse.)

If you're actually interested in writing sex well, I doubt there's a better guide than Resonant's series on How To Write a Sex Scene:

Part 1. Make me yearn. The reader needs to be longing for some resolution in addition to orgasm, so that the described orgasm gets emotional fuel from the drive toward narrative fulfilment along with the physical.

In other words, the sex scene should be part of the *story*, the plot, the narrative. Even in a pure PWP ("Plot? What Plot?" aka "Porn Without Plot" story) there's a narrative, a quality of story-ness the unfolding of the writing along with the shedding of the clothes.

Part 2. Pick one zing and stick to it. That is, a given sex scene can only carry so much weight of meaning and complication, don't try to pack it all in at once. Stick to one major zing and let it carry you all the way for this single scene; other zings, other scenes.

Part 3. Make the sex fit the characters (and not the other way around). This is it, the most crucial point of all. "Don't think about what happens in the scene. Think about what payoff you want from it".

It's all about the characters, because sex is something *people* do. Sex without the human (or sentient alien) dimension is literally mechanical, and (speaking as a biologist) it *cannot* be as arousing as sex with a true person. Not to mention that it doesn't make for interesting writing. Sex as an expression of character is (should be) the Gold Standard for pornographic writing, though I have only seen this explicitly acknowledged for slash. It's quite possible that theoreticians of romance novels, mainstream genre porn, het fanfic, or pro gay porn also refer to this standard, but I just don't know as much about those fields.

Notably, a number of the commenters to Res' post said that even without knowing the show or the characters, this single sentence is an effective sex scene:

"Jesus, Rodney -- say something so I -- know it's you," and Rodney's going to put his mouth right against John's ear and say very quietly, "You know it's me".


[I could give a hyper-detailed analysis of why & how this single sentence works so well, but that might be overkill. Ask, though, and I'll dance for you like a monkey.]

Part 4. Choose your details carefully. You don't have to put in *all* the details, just the ones that: 1. support the yearning you're trying to create, 2. support your zing, 3. tell us something about the character and the relationship, 4. we need to know about it to understand what happens next, and 5. really turn you on.

Just as mathematicians historically felt uneasy about Euclid's Fifth Postulate, I'm not so sure about this Fifth Principle of Writing Sexy Details. What I too often see is a writer being so distracted by what turns *her* on that she forgets the other factors, especially the question of whether this is a turn-on for *this* character in *this* circumstance. I suspect that the "what turns you on" decision needs to be made earlier, in the yearn/zing part of story development, so that when you get down to details the characters tell *you* what turns them on, instead of you telling *them*.

And if the characters never speak to you? You probably shouldn't be writing about them.


  • I would add one more thing: the sex has to be part of the story. Even in erotica this isn't always the case. A sex scene that's plopped down with no rhyme or reason is about as arousing as sex without any sort of foreplay. A sex scene has to be integrated into the story just like anything else.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 11:11 AM  

  • HiFriends!

    Impressive webpage! I like it a lot! I'm looking forward to the next update
    [url=]70 yr old pussy[/url]
    [url=]aebn nude boy videos[/url]

    [url=]anal girl lesbian sex[/url]
    [url=]applegate free nude pics[/url]
    [url=]asian teen lesbian sex[/url]
    very thanks

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:18 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home